I know it's early, but I wanted to post an update to my case study before the end of the year, as time is probably going to be very limited in January. Here's chapter 21 of my case study. Hope you enjoy :)
- Months 1-3
- Month 4
- Month 5
- Month 6
- Month 7
- Month 8
- Month 9
- Month 10
- Month 11
- Month 12
- Month 13
- Month 14
- Month 15
- Month 16
- Month 17
- Month 18
- Month 19
- Month 20
Current stats
108 posts (+5)
246,769 words (+12,825)
576 subscribers (+27)
10,047 page views
Earnings: $4.36
What was my plan going into December?
These were my modest goals for December.
I want to try and make December my best month yet. How? I'm going to promote my new content to the best of my abilities :) I'm also planning on sending hundreds of emails again, in order to further improve my authority.
I'm also planning on publishing 4 more articles in December, of which 2 are outsourced.
Hopefully, the growth on the SERPs will then pick up again.
That last one isn't really a goal, but more on that later :)
Similar to November, December was a very hectic month (much more hectic than I would like). If you're not interested in this bladiebla nonsense, then skip ahead. But here's a little context.
Life
I mentioned it at the start of the case study, but I work full time as an engineer, specifically in renewable energy. This market is currently booming. The amount of windfarms in the North Sea is exploding, and my employer obviously wants a piece of that cake. However, engineers are currently not easy to find, so our relatively small team has not grown as much as the market demands.
Therefore, I feel like I've been running at 150% for the last couple of months. All my work is on a computer (if I'm not in meetings) so after work, dinner, quality time with the girlfriend and exercising, it's hard to find time AND discipline to write a blog post or find prospects to email.
Luckily though, I have this discipline thing down. It's my biggest skill in my opinion. I keep going even though I can think of a lot of other shit that I'd rather do.
Around the 20th of December, I felt super tense and pressured and honestly burned out. Luckily, my office shuts down during Christmas, so I now have 10 days off or something. I needed this so hard, I probably wouldn't have lasted a week longer.
That's the thing: I'm so passionate and optimistic about this project that I may be taking it a little too far. My discipline is allowing me to be very productive, but it's also keeping me from taking things slowly.
That's what I want to change going into 2019. I want to take things easier, both at work and with this project, even when it's going to affect my productivity. My sanity and sleep are much more important than the growth of this website (even though the website is constantly on my mind).
Anyway, that's where I am personally at the moment. Let's dive into what I managed to do in December.
What I did
Marketing!
I wanted to make December my best month yet.
Despite trying a lot, I unfortunately have to admit that I didn't make it. I tried a LOT of things to get people to land on my cornerstone content, but only had moderate success.
I was initially dissapointed, but meh I've still learned some things that I might be able to use later.
What I tried.
- Posting in different subreddits
My posts did well, but didn't take off like they sometimes do. Two of my posts that did well (>50 upvotes within 1 hour) got taken down by the mods. :( Reddit is very hard to crack, but hey, that's the game we're in right?
- Posted on hackernews
I don't understand their algorithm AT ALL. I posted multiple articles but the post with the least upvotes was progressed to their frontpage... HOW? This resulted in 4,000 pageviews or something. It didn't manage to stay long, but it was still nice to see some success. It's very hard to replicate though...
- Emailed big websites (Huff Post, Business Insider and a couple of others)
No replies yet.... I want to buff up my DA by getting some GOOD links. Any tips here?
- Emailed another 150 webmasters via my shared outreach method.
This only resulted in 2 backlinks, from blogs with DA's of 2 and 15. I was definitely hoping for more...
- Responded to any HARO query that I found relevant
I made it a goal to respond to any query. I did it before (about 5 times) without ever getting a reply, but I still continued. After 1 week or something, I got notified of the fact that UpJourney used me as a source.
Hurray!
UpJourney is a FAST growing website. When they published my link, their DA was "only" 26 (same as mine). It has already grown to 30 (just 2 weeks later!). This website is quote promising, as they are publishing a shitload of content in my niche. However, they are 100% driven by guest posts, so I'm afraid that the effect of this backlink will be reduced. Just speculating here. A backlink is still a backlink :)
I'm continuing to slowly grow my backlink profile like this, and I will definitely continue!
What else did I do besides this marketing?
Content!
I published 5 more articles, of which 4 are highly targeted on keywords that I theoretically should be able to rank for.
1 of those pieces of content was outsourced to the same writer as before. At the moment, there's 1 more outsourced article in the pipelines. So far, so good :)
The results?
The result of all this work is slowly coming.
- This is how much Ahrefs thinks I'm growing
- This is how much Semrush thinks I'm growing
- This is how my best ranking article has climbed the SERPs: I've done nothing to that article since publishing in May 2018, so I'm very optimistic about the future growth of my website.
- My "money" post hit the first page, so it's cool to see daily clicks to Amazon. It's currently at #8 or something. Hopefully this can take over #1 in a couple of months.
Things are looking up!
Plans for 2019
In addition to taking things more slowly, here's what I expect will happen in 2019.
- My website will hit 200 daily pageviews by March
- My website will hit 500 daily pageviews by August
- My website will hit 1000 daily pageviews before the end of 2019
How?
- By waiting for 10+ articles (similar to the one I published back in May) to start ranking.
- By publishing similar articles, based on good keyword research
- By continuing to slowly grow my link profile
Monetizing?
Yes.
I want to sign up for Ezoic or Mediavine when I can (hopefully before the end of 2019.
Also, I want to publish (outsource) more money posts, as I'm seeing the potential there.
Any income that I can catch will be reinvested in the website, to hopefully continue the exponential growth that I'm currently in. I'm investing more and more in this website already anyway, as my confidence is quite high.
I'm hoping 2019 is the year that my website becomes profitable. I want to make this work.
That's it I guess. Any questions or feedback is much appreciated! :)
EDIT.
After great feedback from u/reigorius, I've used this last day of the year to redesign my website. It's mostly color changes and a shiny logo (very happy with that one). This is why I publish these case studies! :)
Comments from Reddit
u/getyouredge · 2 points
200k words and that little earnings?
Maybe you should focus on building links to 1 content, on a high volume keyword thats significantly easier to rank for.
Focusing on pillar content, then branch out when money comes in might just seem easier.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
My priority has never been earnings, call me an idiot if you want ;-)
Getting traffic to the site and building a following is priority #1. I'll worry about money later. I feel like I'm working quite well towards these goals.
u/getyouredge · 2 points
Traffic is not just to make money, it's a proof of concept how much of an impact you are bringing to people.
If people are willing to spend = solving their problems.
If you are going after the self help type of deal like mark manson, for the number of words you wrote - you should be in a different league in terms of traffic sources.
But blindly writing a ton of article w/o much traffic just seems unneccessary tbh.
Pillar content > Notice comments stating they are interested > expand supporting content
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
this reply from this thread should explain it
Let's just say I took the long way... I'd do it again if I had to start over. Again, I don't do this exclusively for profits.
u/James44d · 2 points
Thats cool and all, but you're acting like monetisation and growing the site are mutually exclusive things.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
That's not my intention. I'm only trying to explain why I have this much content and no earnings to show for it.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 0 points
I'm not sure but from what I read online it's a minimum of 10k. It's a little too early for me now ;-)
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
Interesting! Thanks for sharing guys
u/esporter113 · 1 point
Very cool update! I like hearing your progress because you have one of the more interesting niches I've seen.
By the way, your stuff might do really well on Pinterest. I have two niches that are both well-suited to Pinterest and have taken a break from writing new content to figure it out.
I could really see articles like "10 things to let go of to be happy" and "Grateful vs Thankful" doing great there.
Early returns have been quite good for me! I think people who blog on the right topics should definitely check it out as it can really accelerate your growth and it doesn't get talked about enough in niche site circles.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
Thanks!
I tried Pinterest before, pinning a lot of my stuff so I already have a pretty populated Pinterest account. I think my previous strategy was not good enough (I didn't utilize group boards and only pinned manually).
I want to give it another try in 2019, as I agree with you: I think my articles could do well on Pinterest. Do you maybe have some articles on strategies that work? :)
u/esporter113 · 1 point
When I heard someone say that Pinterest was really a lot more like Google than people think, that kind of cracked it open for me.
(Well, I wouldn't say I've cracked it, but so far I'm seeing great progress.)
The idea is to be active, pin your stuff, and pin other people's stuff consistently, basically every day, for a long period of time. It might be 4-8 months before you start to build up enough authority with Pinterest for them to really serve your content to people. (Sound familiar?)
So between the two sites I run, I have about 200 pieces of content. The past few weeks I've built out boards on both accounts and have been going through and creating/pinning a few images every day, plus a handful of other people's pins to my various boards.
Before I write the description and pin, I use the smart search bar to find keywords people are searching for in Pinterest that might be a fit and include those in the description.
That's pretty much it.
I think in 2019 I'll invest in a scheduler like Tailwind to make things easier once I have the bulk of the up-front work done. From there it won't be that much work to create images when I write a new post and occasionally problem solve pins that aren't doing well.
My reach, impressions, and clicks to my site are all improving dramatically for both accounts. The one site, in particular, started at 0 and within a few weeks of actively pinning (like 6-7 days per week), I'm getting 50-100 visits to the site every day from Pinterest. That's pretty awesome for not having to write any new content. I expect that to have at least some carryover or least correlation to Google rankings eventually.
The other site has been a little slower to catch on, but all metrics are going up and I'm only a few weeks in.
I've heard a lot of people say recently that group boards aren't really that great anymore unless you can find some really good ones, but I haven't tried it yet so I can't say.
In a few months if all goes well I may do a case study on just this. For the right niches, Pinterest is just an insane opportunity.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
That case study would be very interesting! Sign me up.
But 50-100 visitors per day already sounds like a great success to me. Especially after just 7 weeks. By reading your comment alone, Pinterest has just moved up the ranks on my priority list haha.
Hopefully I'll be able to follow what you do.
Thanks for sharing your numbers!!
u/reigorius · 1 point
I found your Pinterest profile and you really need font S.O.S. when you go after Pinterest again.
I think /u/omglia has put up a nice tutorial on her slayingsocial.com site.
u/AWrig90 · 1 point
Just to chime in here, I've had some modest success with Pinterest and found it by far the best source of social traffic. My strategy was simply to Pin a shitload of stuff and apply to as many relevant group boards as you can! Make sure to make custom images for your Pins, I use Canva. After some success validates that you have an audience there just bite the bullet and get Tailwind. I was spending about an hour a day on Pinterest and after setting up Tailwind I'm spending about an hour every 2 weeks scheduling everything.
The main thing you need to do is get accepted into a popular group board though. Once you do that you'll start to see your Pins gaining a lot more traction, which in turn increases followers and website visits. As with any social media, after that it's a snowball effect. Unlike other social media, you'll still be getting website visits from Pins you published months ago.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
Thanks for weighing in! I'm convinced I have to give it another shot, especially since I disregarded group boards during my last try. Also, my designs were lazy and mass-produced. I can do better.
u/AWrig90 · 1 point
Yeah group boards are an absolute must. Even now with around 1.1k followers the majority of my traffic comes from group boards.
Hit me up when you're giving it another go too. There's a a few boards and group boards that some of your travel related articles would fit in to. I'd be happy to repin them and see if it makes a difference.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
Will do! :) Thanks for the offer.
u/reigorius · 1 point
So do you repin the same content over and over & how much per day? And how much of it is your own?
u/AWrig90 · 2 points
Yeah I make a few different images for each blog post and pin them across a bunch of boards. I total around 12 pins per day of my own content and probably the same amount from other users
u/BxlMaBelle · 1 point
Question from a noob; what do you mean with " highly targeted on keywords". How do you know what keyword to use best?
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 2 points
It's based on keyword research. Basically, I only wrote this content because I predict I can rank for a specific set of keywords which would result in SE traffic. I really suggest you read a lot about keyword research and test & plan for yourself.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 2 points
Thanks! There's a logical explanation to me:
My site has 3 categories. I spent the first year building category 1, which has by far the most content. (about 175.000 words I guess).
This category is not suitable for keyword targeting (it's basically an online journal). Why the hell do I have this content then? Because it's still the foundation upon which my idea is built, and category 2 would not exist without category 1.
Category 2 is more focused on keywords, but pretty competitive so far. I do get some traffic to these pages. This category serves better as link magnets though!
Category 3 is where my growths at. I launched this category in month 14. This category targets a broader niche and allows me to really target those low competition keywords. Pretty much all my growth in the SERP's is coming from this category.
Knowing that this category is "only" 7 months old, it's pretty logical to me that it's still this low. That's the explanation that I want to use.
Another - less favorite - explanation is that I am a fucking idiot and I have no idea what I'm doing. I prefer my first explanation.
I have 1 article that is a "best of" review article with links to Amazon. It's the money post I refer to in my case study and it's been mostly an experiment : very low volume keyword with competition that I should be able to beat.
Indeed, I'm primarily focused on growing traffic first. I'll worry about income later.
u/thattexasgrind · 2 points
Are you doing all of the KW research and SEO yourself?
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 3 points
I've done everything myself. It's my first website and I had to Google the difference between WordPress.com and WordPress.org when I started. I knew nothing.
u/[deleted] · 2 points
20 months in and you still aren't making anything or worried about income? That's either really stupid or really brilliant.
Wouldn't it make sense to start trying out some monetization methods now just so you can validate the quality of your traffic and your content strategy going forward?
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
Haha thanks. I've only been worried about getting traffic up to now, and it's still by far my biggest priority. I still consider this to be my passion project, I feel satisfied by making good content and helping others. This does not necessarily have to replace my paycheck :)
My one and only money post is doing alright I suppose, so that's something haha.
u/reigorius · 2 points
Hey Hugo, I've been following your case studies for a while now and I am in awe with your self discipline and what you are building online.
I'd like to add a bit of constructive feedback. As a designer there are a couple of things I suggest you look at the next time you have a bit of free time left in your busy schedule.
The gifs you use, especially the one on the first page, lack a certain finesse or with a lack for a better word, authority. The 'real estate' of an Ipad or other common tablet is larger than the one you use as a template. It has massive black bars on all sides. Edit:on mobile it seems to shrink the gif, but not the black bars. Also the Excel or Google worksheet itself doesn't look that inviting. Tiny text, no colors, labor insensitive and such. Also the name worksheet isn't that inticing, because of the word 'work'. It's quite easy to turn a dull looking Excel file into a neat looking document where you guide a non-worksheet user through it. But of course it's best to use a dedicated app that does the same. But I assume that is something you have planned long term.
Maybe have some or more screenshots that clearly show the increase of happiness on a chart in a more visually appealing way instead of gifs. I dislike gifs as I can't pause them, distract me and when used improperly, annoys me to no end.
Also the colors used on your site are a bit bland. When I think of happiness, I think of mix of bright, saturated or soft colors that mix well. On color-hex you can find some nice palettes that might support your site much better than the baby blue and call to action orange you have now. If you throw a look at on of our case study submitters, practicalwanderlust.com, the impression of her site is one of bright and soft colors and just scream happiness and harmony. At the moment your blog feels a bit dull and technical, and the worksheet industrial. Make it shine.
And your site really needs a logo. You can make one in Canva if you don't want to spend money on it. I suggest trying to mix a hand written font with a sans serif font. And on that matter, the fonts used in the image from the December 24th post is not ideal. Just use a clear white capitalised sans serif font. Don't over think it. I suggest visiting 'the futur' Youtube site and find the fonts videos. So make it look like this: https://imgur.com/a/zyWX8U3
Right, the logo I spot in your post image, no. Just no. I'll make you a place holder until you have a better one. Here you go:
https://i.imgur.com/W63CXwL.png
I spend like a minute on it, but it works as a placeholder. PM if you want the EPS/AI file. Font the font-impaired among us: fonts used is Akzidenz-Grotesk (paid font, so use Roboto) and Grand Hotel.
More fundamental, when I go online I often have only two reason. One is to be entertained or to solve a problem. In your niche, happiness or the lack there of is a huge issue to a lot of people out there. Everybody has moments or periods in their lives where everything seems dark and sad. So a lot of people search for ways to get happier, which btw means a perfect opportunity to make money, right now. Your landing page on your domain doesn't seem to tap into that primal urge to find a way to get happy/happier. 'What gets measured, gets managed' sounds in theory promising, but doesn't acknowledge that a visitor is sad or aching to find a way to get happier.
When you decide to focus on money making (I suppose with an app?), I suggest throwing out a hook into the personal feelings of your visitor and pinpoint that lack of happiness and suggest a proven way of increasing it. A text like:
'Always wanted to know why one day you are happy and the next it all seems lost?
And
'Track how you feel each day with this easy app and increase your happiness.'
Might work better or try to come up with something to that extent. Right now the first few lines don't really seem to be optimized to convert visitors.
Keep up the great work!
Edit: on mobile, so I will add links and such later. Post in progress.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
I'm not going to wait for you to finish your comment lol.
THANKS so much for taking the time to give me this feedback. I really appreciate it. I was planning on preparing a couple of articles tomorrow (I have a day off yet my gf has to work so there's some time), but now want to fix these things that you mention here.
If you're okay with it, I'll message you personally to discuss my plan? Is that cool?
Thanks again. It's comments like these that help me grow, especially since I'm as vanilla as it gets with design and copywriting. :)
u/reigorius · 1 point
Just one dude helping another dude. Je mag me PM-en, en check de links die ik heb toegevoegd.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
PM underway! :)
u/reigorius · 1 point
It is what this sub is about in my opinion. I also like this story very much:
https://old.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/elal2/have_you_ever_picked_up_a_hitchhiker/c18z0z2/
u/wirez62 · 1 point
That sounds awesome, you're way ahead of me in action. Mines just getting off the ground. I focused on amazon early but it will take me months to see sales and traffic so it's not like I'm some guru! I was just reading like "woah, theres no way I can hit 250k words", that's an amazing amount. And category 3 sounds cool. I think this will all work out huge for you, starting with a ton of content and increasing traffic numbers with plans for growth I bet you are so close to the tipping point of traffic explosion.
u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point
I'm really hoping you are right haha. Everything is pointing in the right direction, my rankings are growing so I hope this snowball effect will happen the next couple of months.