✕

Case Study (Month 28) - Doubling down (on stupid?)

7,254 words

Edit: This case study was featured on the ahrefs blog with a dofollow link. LOL. Let's seize the situation to experiment. Since the Ahrefs blog has strong authority, this post on Reddit will receive some of the link juice. Let's siphon some of it back to my site with a link. Even though the relevancy of both this Reddit post and the Ahrefs blog is low, let's still see how much effect it can have.

Want to learn how happiness works? More specifically, how you can be happier? I'm sure the answer is yes! Well then, here is a place on the internet filled with actionable tips, examples and science-backed guides on how to be happy!

That's it for the experiment. Since the ahrefs article used my case study as an example of something that you DON'T want (lol), you should just click away now! ;-) If not, enjoy the read!

Since engagement on my case studies has been pretty shit lately, I'm gonna try to do things differently. What this means is that I'll cover what's been happening this last month in a bulleted list, ranking from big to small.

To be honest, I've thought about quitting this case study a lot this past month, since the value that I get from it (user interaction & feedback) has been lacking. If you're a lurker who appreciates this series, or if you have a strong opinion and want to show me what I could do better, I'd love for you to come out of the shadows and leave your thoughts below.

Actually, be gentle on me, please, since this month has been pretty conflicting (in lack of better words...) I'm doubling down on my website (investing more and more into it) with no sign of profitability in the near future. Am I an idiot? Find out right away and let me know what you think.

If you're looking for the giant table with the metrics etc, it's at the bottom. Here comes my list of things that happened, starting at the top with the most interesting:

  • The verdict on the June algo update is in: I was hit harder than I expected. An entire category of my website (which I mainly use for content marketing/acquiring backlinks) has been slammed to death. Here's what it looks like. Now, these articles are all YMYL related, and Google has obviously decided that my website has not enough EAT to compete with the big boys. Ugh. This is what accounted for the 20-25% drop in traffic. Anyway, traffic is not down, but also not up by as much as I'd hoped. For the amount of content I'm pushing, I was hoping for more. I'm still optimistic though.
  • Related: Google just released this statement about algo updates. This is a good read for anyone, really, but more importantly, get comfortable with the Search Quality Rater Guidelines right away. That Marie Heynes article that Google refers to is really informative and covers EAT in depth.
  • Let's stick with EAT. I've been focusing hard to try and improve my EAT. But what the fuck is EAT anyway? I think I've had the wrong idea up until recently. I thought Google had methods to verify and prove authority (via the amount of factual data you use in articles, the way you write, your actual profile pic, your credentials, your outgoing links, etc), but I've come to accept now that that is total BS. It's still all about the fucking backlinks. Google is not as smart as most noobs think (myself included), even though they try to make it seem that way. Perfect example, examine.com was recently crushed in another big update, even though they seem to follow Google guidelines to a T. This is a must read. In the meantime, there are still sites - some of which are my competitors - that are thriving without showing ANY on-page EAT factors. What do they have instead? Yup, backlinks.
  • That brings me to my next point: I need more backlinks. Especially backlinks from big websites. How am I going to do that? By simple guest-posting. I've narrowed down a couple of big websites (DR > 70) that publicly accept guest posts. I've always decided against doing this, because I thought Google would see how these sites are built on guest posts, and therefore, any links gained on there will be discounted. Well, screw that. I'm going for it anyway. I'm going to write guest posts (or outsource it) and send them out in the next month or so.
  • Speaking of writers: I have properly experienced what it's like to outsource on Upwork. In the last 6 weeks or so, I have 1) found the perfect writer, 2) lost the perfect writer after 3 articles, 3) trialed 6 other writers, 4) hired another great writer (which is still with me), 5) sacked 1 writer who didn't communicate properly, and 6) am still looking for more writers. I pay $30 per article, and so far, I've outsourced 8 articles.
  • I'm doubling down. I'm in the process of removing myself as the bottleneck (something I've been wanting to do for a long time already). What does this mean? Well, I've created a road map that will bring me to an income of >$500 per month within 12 months. This road map is based on my existing data and performance so far (which I consider to be conservative). What this comes down to is: doubling my content creation, outsourcing 80% of it, so I can focus more on links/other venues. I'm trying to spend up to $300 on content creation per month now (this buys me 10 articles). In July, I managed to spend $180, which is why I'm still looking for additional writers.
  • Am I doubling down on stupidity? Maybe. I showed my road map with people I trust, and 90% of them advised me against it. "It" being: investing this much in a website without any signs of profitability. To be honest, I don't give a damn, and just want to see how this works out. This case study will either be a perfect example of sunk cost fellacy, stupidity and stubborness. But I am still optimistic that it can become an example of determination and perseverance. I usually circle back to this comment on one of my case studies that best explains my motivation.
  • I published 11 articles. Pretty happy with this, though I want this to be more. These articles are all based on my extensive keyword research (see last months update), and I fully expect these to carry my growth the next couple of months.
  • I turned off Ezoic ads completely. Why? 1) Because my page speed was affected badly, both visually and according to Google Pagespeed Insights (which I take seriously). Prior to turning it off, my mobile score was ~30. After turning it off, it went up to ~80. 2) My ad revenue was pathetic to begin with: RPM of <$2.00, so not even $25 a month. I'm not going to miss that. My plan for now is to just wait for my traffic to grow to the Mediavine level, and try to get on their platfrom once that happens.
  • Google sent a traffic spike from the Phillipines to my site. This is what it looks like. It's not bot traffic, since analytics shows different IP addresses and location data for all these visitors. UX metrics are OK too. So they are real visitors. Most of this traffic goes to 1 article, which is strange because that article is not that good to begin with, and also doesn't target any keywords that get so much volume. My biggest explanation for this traffic spike is that some "event" in the Phillipines has wildly increased the search volume for some english terms, and my website is on top there by coincidence. I honestly don't know and don't care, since my website doesn't target these people either way.
  • I'm still receiving really heartwarming comments/emails from my readers from time to time, which to me means a lot more than any ad revenue. Funnily enough, I also get some hate sometimes. This example is pretty nice.
  • I'm running out of bullet points, as you might have noticed it gets less interesting down here.
  • Oh, the last few months I've experimented with publishing content that targets 0 search keywords. Specifically, keywords that don't get any searches according to the tools, but are still recommended by google as you type in the search (this is basically income school's method for response posts). My honest opinion so far (after publishing the first post 2 months ago) is that it works. Since competition is non-existent on these keywords, I consistently rank on page 1 (top 5) within a month or so, and from there, I slowly grow to top 3 (or even #1 and #0 combined). This results in about 100 pageviews per month on some of these posts. After just 2 months, I think this is fantastic. Don't get me wrong, 100 pageviews are not a lot, but since these response posts are so easy to find and write, I consider this to be a success.
  • I'm still using HARO every month to both pitch myself as a source (I'm REALLY hoping to land a link from Bustle soon... fingers crossed) and to get crowd-sourced content written for me. I'm still a happy user of HARO, and consider it to be very powerful for something that is free!

That's it.

Again, this month was conflicting for me since I'm doubling down on this website that is not even close to being profitable. Let me know what you think.

Goals for the future:

  • Continue this high amount of content production
  • Invest $300 per month in the site (content content content)
  • Acquire some bigger backlinks by whatever means necessary (I might even pay for it)
  • Eventually monetize the website properly (long-term goal).

How can I monetize the website long-term? 1) running ads properly, 2) selling my own product (ebook/course), 3) developing an app, 4) more affiliate posts (I'm the least enthusiastic about this one, even though it's probably the easiest to do).

See you next month (maybe).

Month TLDR Wordcount Articles Total users Organic users Subscribers Revenue
Months 1-3 Getting started, Bluehost shared hosting, writing articles that will never rank 30,000 15 520 18 - -
Month 4 Writing more articles that will never rank, basic outreach (not succesful) 38,325 (+8,325) 21 (+6) 3,374 9 - -
Month 5 Continuing, slowly writing cornerstone content 50,227 (+11,902) 26 (+5) 1,693 10 11 -
Month 6 Got extremely lucky and organically got a huge backlink (DA > 80) 57,611 (+7,384) 31 (+5) 1,555 6 53 (+42) -
Month 7 Found some success sharing on Reddit, built a number of backlinks 67,625 (+10,014) 37 (+6) 1,707 7 105 (+52) -
Month 8 Trying social media, Twitter, FB, Pinterest and Instagram with iMacros (lazy approach) 81,147 (+13,522) 44 (+7) 1,606 19 203 (+98) -
Month 9 Migrated from Bluehost to Siteground, instantly decreasing my loading times, still not working on keyword research... 97,241 (+16,094) 52 (+8) 6,831 26 198 (-5) -
Month 10 Not a lot of time, low motivation, not a lot happening here 104,267 (+7,026) 56 (+4) 605 36 208 (+10) -
Month 11 First guest post (DA ~ 40), Google is starting to rank my pages but still nothing special, most importantly: created a roadmap to take this site to the next level 122,248 (+17,981) 64 (+8) 1,964 44 200 (-8) -
Month 12 Posting a lot of necessary content, wanting to complete a section before expanding. 145,765 (+23,517) 71 (+7) 1,405 73 200 (-) -
Month 13 Redesigned my entire website, from free theme to GeneratePress + Beaver Builder, purchased Serpstat for some much needed SEO knowledge. Transfered my email list to MailerLite 160,081 (+14,316) 76 (+5) 941 95 240 (+40) -
Month 14 Doing a big backlink campaign 168,440 (+8,359) 80 (+4) 1,735 154 255 (+15) -
Learning all about backlink building and update here Posts discussing my linkbuilding efforts - - - - - -
Month 15 Too busy at work and on holiday, created a welcome email sequence with Mailerlite, following my big roadmap 168,440 (-) 80 (-) 1,046 157 261 (+6) -
Month 16 Published my best article yet, got some backlinks to it, reached the frontpage of hacker news! 179,352 (+10,912) 85 (+5) 34,585 384 364 (+103) -
Month 17 Got a little burned out, but FINALLY starting to focus on keyword focuses articles! Google is starting to like my website from this moment onward. 187,031 (+7,679) 89 (+4) 5,497 355 402 (+38) -
Month 18 Another round of backlink building, slowly growing in Google, avoided the Medic update, another article reaching the frontpage of hacker news 197,179 (+10,148) 93 (+4) 19,620 431 492 (+90) -
Outlining my future plans for the website - - - - - - -
Month 19 Published my first Amazon review article, continued to publish content with good keyword research, tried outsourcing some content creation, slowly reaching 100 PV/day, setting the goal of 1000 PV/day within 12 months 212,191 (+15,012) 97 (+4) 6,315 826 518 (+26 ) -
Month 20 Added loads of authority to my site, revealed my name and face, got approved to Amazon Associates, migrated my site from Siteground to Cloudways, linkbuilding and content creation 233,944 (+21,753) 103 (+6) 2,182 912 549 (+31) $6.81
Month 21 Extremely busy at work, emailed some big websites pitching myself as contributor, finding HARO, growing in Google, some more success on hacker news and reddit 246,769 (+12,825) 108 (+5) 8,013 929 576 (+27) $4.36
Month 22 Overhauled the design and finally happy with it! Got accepted as a contributor to Lifehack.org, slowly receiving more organic links, continuing to publish good content focused on keywords 266,000 (+13,231) 113 (+5) 3,860 1,805 532 (+56) $2.77
Month 23 Biggest backlink so far (DA 88), more organic backlinks, nice growth in Google, learning more about HARO, planned interview with Authority Magazine and Thrive Global 276,848 (+10,848) 117 (+4) 4,128 2,620 657 (+25) $8.78
Month 24 First >300 organic pageviews day, starting to use a new method for content creation, surviving another Google update, continuing Google growth, good times! 293,192 (+16,344) 123 (+6) 8,123 3,813 685 (+28) $17.31
Month 25 Only able to work on the website for 15 days. Was still super productive. Activated Ezoic ads. Posted an article created by one of my readers (awesome). Wrote more "response posts". Google growth stalled for now. 309,746 (+16,554) 130 (+7) 7,222 5,546 715 (+30) $24.07
Month 26 Probably my most productive month so far. Wrote 10 articles, of which 1 lifehack guest post. Updated email marketing sequences, hit 500+ organic pageviews on some days, everything is growing! 336,430 (+26,684) 139 (+9) 11,514 7,536 770 (+55) $44.86
Month 27 Lots of time off (holidays) and a little burned out. Redefined my roadmap to future growth, going to invest more in the website, found 2 writers on Upwork, got hit by June 2019 update. 351,811 (+15,386) 145 (+6) 10,124 8,373 625 (-145) $52.91
Month 28 Found some great writers on Upwork, trying to upscale content creation, traffic is plateauing for now. Back at ~500 PV/day on weekdays. 378,233 (+26,422) 156 (+11) 10,963 9,189 648 (+23) $38.16

Comments from Reddit

u/esporter113 · 5 points

Hey man, I love your case studies. They have a lot of heart and personality in them, not just how many words you wrote last month :)

I'm sorry to hear about your struggle to find your footing in Google. EAT is a tricky bastard, and you're right that I do think a lot of it comes down to backlinks. I also find myself intrigued by those in the SEO community who don't really believe that Google has the tools to vet authority qualitatively, and that EAT is mostly an algorithmic thing.

IE, does the site owner have a real name visible on the site? Is there an easy to find email address on the site? Is there a real physical address listed on the site? Stuff like that.

What is your roadmap to get to the $500 per month mark? Are you thinking you'll be able to get your traffic up to MediaVine standards and then implement that to get most of the way there?

And thanks for sharing the thread from the Examine.com guys, extremely illuminating!

u/MeekSeller · 3 points

I also find myself intrigued by those in the SEO community who don't really believe that Google has the tools to vet authority qualitatively.

Depends by what you are referring to as "qualitatively" Every time thousands of searches are analyzed, the data strongly suggests they don't. If they do, they are not working as intended. This may change in the future but this is the present iteration of Googles Algorithm.

does the site owner have a real name visible on the site? Is there an easy to find email address on the site? Is there a real physical address listed on the site? Stuff like that.

Google isn't going to de-rank sites for not having them. Every site is different. What you listed MIGHT be best practice for a local plumber. It isn't necessarily for your run-of-the-mill affiliate site.

Here is a freebie for you guys, to illustrate my point:

www.foodsharkmarfa.com

Ranks for 1st for some very juicy keywords.

I can point out examples like this all day. Where are your "EAT" best practices there? Backlinks are still king, backed up by content that is "good enough"

u/esporter113 · 1 point

Yeah, fair. I think some of these things matter more in some niches vs others.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Hey meek, now that I have you here, can I ask for your honest opinion on what you think of my plans? ;-)

u/MeekSeller · 5 points

I'll admit, I have not been following along monthly but I don't really see a plan other than "invest more in writers"

None of what follows is having a dig at you, please take it as disjointed constructive criticism.

I think you should be less focused on "more articles" and refine what you have before building out. I assume the goal IS to make money out of this at some point, since you are working towards that goal of >$500/m within 12 months. How are you going to do that? What is the action that is going to transfer money from a visitor to you? Is it display ads? Is it your happiness tracker? Is it "spend a night of happiness with the site owner?" It doesn't matter what it is, but all future content (and existing trafficked content) should be build around that focus. For example, I don't imagine your "thankful vs. grateful" article is attracting the kind of people you would want.

"I want to be happy" or "reasons to be happy" on the other hand, are great keywords that are much more likely to align with your core focus.

Your existing content is very... Wordy. Especially on mobile.

https://www.trackinghappiness.com/what-is-your-why/

Sure, it's got your lovely smiling face and a bio, but no one cares. This should just contain your name in text, save the description for the bio.

Next, you have centered text. It's hard to read. Still no pictures.

Next, you have a stock image of someone holding a plant. No one is ever going to share that. Immediate thought is that all your photos should have readable quotes, quotes are shared all the time, we have a sub dedicated to motivated quotes here on reddit. I did see quotes on other images in other articles, but they are small and hard to read. Use something like Canva the quote should be dominant, not the picture. If you wanted to take this concept further, add a small caption under each image that says share this quote, which expands to include everyones favorite visual social medias.

As an aside, you don't have "" on your mobile header - this is your brand, shove it down the readers throat.

Your niche is tricky in that your site very much overlaps with the medical niche (depression, counselling, psychology etc.) - any keyword research that already brings up medical related sites, should be avoided, or at least put on the back burner (I don't count psychology today in this - but I do count samhasa.gov)

I also think you should write back to that UK lady and inform her of her comma misuse. She would understand the importance of you pointing out her gross negligence here - even if it is a very delayed reply (If it is delayed, I would comically inform her that "backwards" America is still on the Mayan Calander and that's why it took so long to reply)

To me, this niche seems like it would be easy to build backlinks, mommy blogs, fitness websites, life coaches, etc - they are all fair game. Message in your inbox coming soon re: this.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

None of what follows is having a dig at you, please take it as disjointed constructive criticism.

I can take anything, as long as it's constructive, so thanks for your time. This is why I post these case studies.

What is the action that is going to transfer money from a visitor to you?

For the near-future, I'm betting on ads mostly. But long-term, I think the biggest potential lies in a) a course, b) a book, or c) an app. This is me thinking big, and I don't yet feel ready to focus on these monetizatoin strategies as of yet, which is why I'm now prioritizing traffic growth as much as possible.

all your photos should have readable quotes, quotes are shared all the time

I personally doubt if this is going to be worth it. A lot of sites (lifehack, markmanson, psychologytoday, inc, etc) have either stock images or no images at all. I agree that it would make me stand out more if I had custom branded images with a quote, instead of just stock images. But would it really be worth the time?

But I can test this, and there is no excuse not to do this. I will see if I can improve an already ranking article this way (replace stock images with custom quote images) and see how it affects its rank and UX metrics.

you don't have "" on your mobile header

Fixed. Thanks.

any keyword research that already brings up medical related sites, should be avoided, or at least put on the back burner

Yes, that's what I thought as well. It sucks because there are a lot of things I want to write about. I hope google's definition of medical-related sites doesn't further expand...

I PM'ed you ;-)

u/reigorius · 2 points

IE, does the site owner have a real name visible on the site? Is there an easy to find email address on the site? Is there a real physical address listed on the site? Stuff like that.

How does that work when all you have is a home address? I'd feel uncomfortable advertising my address that way. Also, as an educator, I prefer to have my side-ventures being low-profile to my employer and my professional demographic.

u/MerlinLuchs · 1 point

Don't know where you're located, but in Germany you're actually required by law to put your full name and address on your website if you intend to make money with it.

u/reigorius · 1 point

The Netherlands

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Hey man, thanks again for dropping by!

The Google QRG specifically mention that the EAT rating must be low for pages that don't have any authorship information. But these ratings don't directly feed the algorithm. They are merely used to test the effectiveness of future algo iterations.

I'm seeing more and more that backlinks are the only good proxy that Google currently has to determine these things algorithmically.

BTW, check your pm :)

u/TravisUchonela · 4 points

Same on Ezoic. I can't quit it on the site I use it because the income is worth it, but good Lord does it slow down a site. I had a pro optimize my site and significantly upgraded my hosting and it only went from abysmal to still slow.

As for your strategy, I really don't think going all out on content is the right move. You have so much already, and you're in a niche that doesn't seem to have enormous traffic. sure, keep publishing. But if it were me I'd focus on building links to your pages about best leather journals and how to be happy. Those are tough keywords but you're close to the first page on both of them.

Do you do much with social media? This seems like a niche better suited to Pinterest than google searches?

u/AWrig90 · 2 points

How are you integrating Ezoic, out of interest?

I talked about getting a pro to optimise my site in my recent case study and he took it from abysmal to very good in a few days. The major problem? Ezoic's DNS integration option.

He disabled that and I've switched it over to the WP plugin. Site speed is still high, although Ezoic isn't up to speed yet so there's a chance it could tank my performance again. Might be worth giving it a try if you're using the DNS integration.

u/TravisUchonela · 1 point

Hmm. I'm on DNS. I can't remember now, but I couldn't get the plugin to work when I was setting it up. I guess I should check on that.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Yeah, I went back and forth about this speed thing with my ezoic account manager, but they couldn't offer anything to improve it.

Thanks for your feedback. I'm gonna try to get more links for sure. I hopefully have some good news the next few months.

As for social media, I don't do anything at all. If this whole seo/content plan doesn't work out, I'll have to go hard on Pinterest haha.

u/TravisUchonela · 1 point

I'm not an expert, but your niche looks like it would do well on Pinterest. seems like the kind of topics people may not search for, but are more likely to click on when they see it.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

A lot of people mention this to me. If this contet/SEO experiment fails, then pinterest will be my next target.

u/IHeartAsciiArt · 3 points

Thanks for that really in-depth update! I'm sorry your traffic got hit bad by the Google update, seeing something you've built up get trounced has got to be really frustrating-- not only for you, but for the examine.com people.

I agree with that comment you linked. Your website is just so different from the typical niche/affiliate site that most case studies are about. I skimmed your site a bit and am really impressed with the quality of writing that you're getting from your writers. I have no doubt that over time it will become a really authoritative site and brand for the happiness space. The fact that you get emails from happy readers is proof of that.

As far as if you're stupid for committing to invest $300/mth with essentially zero income, I say do what makes you happy and F everyone who is naysaying you :) (exception is if your gf has issues with it, that would be a more complicated discussion) While it isn't an insignificant amount of cash, $3,000 is basically a nice vacation, a monthly payment for a luxury car, or a bad night at the casino. My point is, people spend money on all kinds of things, most of them on one-time selfish pleasures. Your "vice" is something intent on making other people in the world happy for the long-term. I think there's something admirable about that.

Another POV is that for a startup company, a $300/mth investment isn't that much if you think about it that way. However, this is assuming your investment will pay off, and that you'll get a monetization plan working to at least have the site pay for itself. I think Mediavine will really help you in this area, when you reach that point. Affiliate posts will definitely help-- you don't even need that many. I have just 2 "best X for Y" articles on my site w/ Amazon and other affiliate links, but I promote them above the fold on my homepage, and in the sidebar on every post. So far they are bringing in \~$200/mth ($50-60 of that Amazon). And I don't feel like I'm selling my soul by pushing affiliate links in every piece of content.

Since you'd mentioned page speed, I took a look at your website also to see if there's anything you can tweak to get a faster page load. I notice you are using a lazy loading plugin, which definitely helps the initial load! I've been considering implementing lazy load on my blog at some point as well.

After looking at a few pages, I do have some suggestions that might help you (apologies if you know these things already!):

  • Make GIFs smaller and shorter, and only show them on desktop; show still screenshot JPGs for mobile. The animation GIFs you have on your essays are very cool, but they are huge files-- around or over 1 MB. (Especially the running map one) That will kill mobile loading. I'm not sure what is possible with your site's configuration. Even if you could speed up the animation so they complete in 2-3 seconds would help a bit.
  • Make your images smaller: making sure the image file isn't bigger in pixels than what the final image is displayed at. In particular in the "Continue reading" section at the bottom, the thumbnails are still loading the full size images-- it should be possible to make those load a smaller size (Wordpress has different sizes like "medium"). This is actually something I need to do on my own site as well!
  • You're loading multiple Google graphs in your essays. However it looks like each graph is loading a 1 MB JS file from docs.google.com. I'm not sure if it's possible or easy to change this. It's also a toss-up between the page load and the interactivity. I personally think you could load screenshots of each graph that would still get the point across, but it could be that the interactivity is very important to you.

The blog posts are much smaller, due to not having graphs, and the images there all seem to be sized pretty well.

Some tools that might help are setting up Cloudflare to load your website assets-- this helped my load time. Also the Wordpress plugin Ewwww Image Optimizer can help optimize existing images in your media library, as well as when you upload new ones. Just make sure you have a backup of your site before running a batch on all existing images, in case something goes south. But this has also helped my site.

Hope you don't mind the super long suggestions on page load time. Feel free to ask me about it, or disregard! Keep on killing it!

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Thanks for taking the time to write such a helpful comment! And I'm not just saying that because you're supportive haha.

What you're saying about investing is how I feel about it as well. I don't need the money that I invest in the site right this moment. It would be invested it an index fund if it weren't for this site. And it's not like index funds are completely risk free, right?

If I lose my money without seeing any reward, then do be it. At least I didn't give it my best shot.

That said, I have a list of affiliate post keywords that I collected, and am considering finding a writer that will write me 10 of those. Just to see if I can increase revenue in some other way, whole I'm waiting for big stuff to happen.

And thanks for the technical feedback! Some things I wasn't aware and which I'm going to change right away.

Again, thank you man. It's comments like these (and all the others on here) that make me want to update this case study every month.

u/[deleted] · 3 points

I think Google likes to produce a lot of white paper on what they want the content to be, but that doesn't represent their limitations on ranking content.

EAT is BS. We can do a simple search for "What is the best toothbrush" and quickly realize that Google doesn't care much for its EAT guidelines.

First result. https://www.health.com/oral-health/best-electric-toothbrush

It's garbage. Anyone can write this stuff. Also it's only about 645 words.

Second result. http://nymag.com/strategist/article/best-electric-toothbrushes-dentists.html

A little better, but honestly, this is hardly expert level content. Not even 1500 words.

3rd result http://nymag.com/strategist/article/best-electric-toothbrushes-rechargable.html

Garbage.

4th result https://www.verywellhealth.com/best-toothbrushes-4580356

More garbage

5th result https://www.businessinsider.com/best-electric-toothbrush

I guess this is a little better, but I still don't feel this is the expert level quality that Google likes to wish it could filter.

TL:DR Google is full of bs a lot of times.

u/reigorius · 2 points

nymag.com is a marketing beast btw. They came charging in my niche out of the blue and grabbed no.1 spot with a fuckton of questionable backlinks.

u/[deleted] · 3 points

Exactly why EAT and wordcount and all that mess is BS.

It's more about domain age and backlinks. But mostly about domain age. I still think that's the number 1 factor by far.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

My opinion exactly.

u/DonHijoPadre · 4 points

Well I think if you have close to 400k words without any income, the problem lies with poor keywords selection or poor link building (or a combination of both!) So I don't think throwing more money for more content seems rational here, at least from a business standpoint.

If the project is merely a hobby and makes you happy then keep chugging along with what you're doing. But from a business standpoint, you need to make a return on the time that you've put into the site which either means creating content that has buyer intent or building links to rank articles with buyer intent.

u/AWrig90 · 3 points

You sort of missed the point there I think - The lack of income isn't a problem since he hasn't actually made any real attempt to monetise on the site.

The fact he's getting >9k visitors a month organically shows that his keyword research and backlink efforts are working, but his site is just lacking monetization (by design).

That being said, I do agree with you on some level. Putting extra money into the site for content without any monetization doesn't make much sense from a business point. Although I'd imagine the road map to profit he mentioned might require a level of content that he can't manage alone.

u/reigorius · 1 point

It seems as if /u/trackinghappiness is losing his original focus a bit. As I understood it, it (his blog) is his passion and he is not doing it for the money. But he is now investing money to generate traffic and hopefully income. And is getting frustrated in the process. He might be slowly killing his passion this way.

An ebook or an app seems the way to go to balance the costs and still have fun writing, publishing and interacting with his readers.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

You're right about how my goal is to grow traffic as much as possible at this moment. And yes, I'm a little frustrated at some parts of this process.

But this is in no way killing my passion. In fact, I've never been as passionate as I am right now. That's why I'm doubling down. This whole case study started as a simple blog (see month 1). But I'm now slowly trying to turn this into something much bigger, and I think these are the first steps to get it there.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

He's not wrong though. It's just important that this website of mine is still a passion project. I'm just now slowly trying to turn it into something bigger, because I believe I can get it there. But the first step (in my mind) is to get traffic. After I get traffic, I'll try to give proper monetization a shot.

My 9k organic traffic is still way less than what I had hoped it would be. But I'm still optimistic that I'm bound to grow a lot the next 4-6 months.

BTW, check your pm :)

u/AWrig90 · 1 point

Oh yeah I didn't mean to imply he was 'wrong' as such, just that he might have missed that you're not earning no money because of a lack of traffic, but rather because of a lack of monetization efforts.

It's definitely viable to invest money into a business with a long term plan of monetization and making a return (look at every startup in Silicon Valley.) You just have to make sure that long term plan actually has a chance of working.

But yeah, as you said keeping that passion is important. IIRC you started outsourcing not only because you were the content bottleneck as it were, but also because having to grind out 10 articles a month was turning it into... Well, a grind?

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

but also because having to grind out 10 articles a month was turning it into... Well, a grind?

Good point haha. You got me there, I'm afraid.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Thanks for your feedback. I have to say though that a lot of my content (about 50%) at this point is just a personal diary, really, not focused on any keywords. This skews the results a little. That said, my website still underperforms the average case study on here from a visitor/# of words perspective. That's why I'm going to focus more on backlinks. You're spot on with your second paragraph though. This is still a personal hobby project, but I'm trying to eventually grow it into what I think it can become. Which is a big website that is an authoritative brand (think mrmoneymustache/markmanson etc).

u/OptimalEverything · 2 points

Keep at it, it’s super helpful to read others journeys!

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Thanks. Good to know this shit is helpful :)

u/AUD_USD · 2 points

I haven't posted on here in ages and haven't read many of your prior posts (sorry) but why wait until 19 months in until putting an Amazon review article out?

This really confuses me. It's a trend I've kind of noticed growing a lot over the last year or so lurking here.

Is profit your primary goal with this site?

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Thanks for commenting! I was a big fan of your case study on here. :)

Is profit your primary goal with this site?

No, not really. Although it's also not something that I don't value at all. This started as a passion website (and it still is). Over time, I learned more and more and saw potential for this passion website/blog to grow into something bigger. For it to be something bigger, I want to grow more aggressively, and try out different types of monetization. That single amazon review article was just a test (a successful one for what it's worth).

But for now, my focus is still 100% on growing traffic for now.

u/AUD_USD · 1 point

Thanks!

Personally, I wouldn't spend a cent on Upwork writers if I wasn't sure if the cost had positive net present value. But I'm pretty conservative.

It's obvious you don't want to slog away writing (or editing) Amazon product reviews, and that's fair enough - it's boring, and they could cut commissions at any point in time. You could always start another site for that purpose.

If you're really passionate about the subject, I'd try to emphasise the personal aspect even more to try and attract more recurring visitors and better-position yourself when pitching with HARO. With videos maybe - you're a good-looking guy - what guys want to be (maybe why you got hate) and what girls find attractive. Unless the subject is full of gurus already (I have no idea).

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Haha thanks. That gave me a good laugh. You're right I'm that I need to make this more personal in order to attract more recurring visitors (this is currently just 1% of my traffic if I'm remembering correctly). I'm trying to make every thing a little more down to earth and relatable.

Video would be a potential platform, but I'm not yet that comfortable haha

u/DurbarGhosh · 2 points

Don't quit this casestudy. I like your persistence, even though you don't see results. Pls, keep posting these casestudies. There is low engagement doesn't mean people do not like it. Maybe they just don't have something to tell.

One suggestion, you are really investing too much effort and money on this website. I think you are not making money because you're ignoring to learn it, ignoring to learn how to monetize. You have learned to create backlinks, you have learned to hire writers. Maybe now it's time to learn to monetize it. It will create even a greater casestudy.

Also I think, you ready spend so much on writing, which is great, but maybe you can save some amount and consultant an expert for monetisation. Or you also invite people in this group and similar groups to take a look at your website and see if they have any ideas to monetize your website. This might be difficult, you even might need to change the style of writing, targeting different kinds of keywords or many other things.

Okay that's just my thought, but don't quit.

All the best.

u/[deleted] · 3 points

[deleted]

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Yeah, I was pretty disappointed with ezoic and my small RPM. I'll try again some day, but only when expected revenue exceeds 200$ or something.

As for backlinks profile, last time I checked my DR (ahrefs) was 28 and my DA (moz) is 34/35. If you search through my profile, you'll quickly uncover my site and you can find every link yourself. ;-)

Thanks for commenting!

u/mtlynch · 1 point

1) found the perfect writer, 2) lost the perfect writer after 3 articles,

Can you share more about this? What made them perfect? How did you lose them? I've struggled with finding good writers, and I've even paid up to $65/hr, so I'm curious about how people are finding writers they like.

I turned off Ezoic ads completely. Why? 1) Because my page speed was affected badly, both visually and according to Google Pagespeed Insights (which I take seriously).

I just did this, too, for similar reasons. They were placing too-wide ads on my site that caused horizontal scrolling on mobile. I switched to AdSense and the RPM is about half, but the ads are much less intrusive and spammy.

u/TrackingHappiness (OP) · 1 point

Sure! My first writer was great. He just started out on Upwork when I hired him. He was quick, original, wrote perfectly and was just a blessing. 3 articles later, he said he was going to prioritize other stuff. I checked his Upwork account, and he already had contracts exceeding $1,000 in value. So my cheap-ass budget would be the first to go out of the window. Understandable. I think this will happen a lot more in the future.